November 4, 2016

Spotlight on Stability

Homelessness Prevention

Bay Area Legal Aid helped set new legal precedence, protecting thousands of tenants who have been illegally evicted and ensuring future tenant protections.

Bay Area Legal Aid helped set new legal precedence, protecting thousands of tenants who have been illegally evicted and ensuring future tenant protections.

One evening in the fall of 2013, the Nativi family found themselves locked out of their home and all their belongings thrown into the yard. They had been renting a converted garage unit for several years when the property became the subject of a foreclosure sale. The Nativi’s had known nothing of the foreclosure sale in advance and had ten months remaining under their current lease. Deutsche Bank, which became the new owner after the foreclosure, refused to allow the Nativi’s to stay in their home, despite the time left on their lease.

In Nativi v. Deutsche Bank, the California Court of Appeal, 6th Appellate District held that under the Protecting Tenants at Foreclosure Act (PTFA), the bank had assumed the duty as landlord upon the foreclosure of the property, and that the Nativi’s lease was still in effect. The Nativi family was given back their home and stability in their community. This decision represented a significant victory for tenants who are the collateral victims of foreclosures and opened the door for recourse in state court. As for Ms. Nativi, she said: “What makes me most happy is that this will help other people.”


Our Reach

Bay Area Legal Aid provides free legal help for over 60,000 individuals every year.

number of cases 2015


Your generous support provides legal advice, counsel, and advocacy to ensure Bay Area residents can protect their families, their health, and their livelihoods.

Related Articles

March 22 @ 2:24 pm

BayLegal client and attorney featured in story on SF Tenant Right to Counsel

This story from NBC Bay Area last week (in both print and broadcast versions) highlights the impact of San Francisco’s…

March 22 @ 2:24 pm

California Supreme Court Accepts Case Brought to Protect Constitutional Rights of Low-Income Litigants

For Immediate Release Thao WeldyFamily Violence Appellate Projecttweldy@fvaplaw.org510-858-7358 Oakland, CA (February 20, 2025) – The California Supreme Court has accepted…

March 22 @ 2:24 pm

DMV holds for bridge tolls return, along with deep inequities

A story by Noah Baustin in today’s San Francisco Standard examines the post-pandemic return of DMV registration holds for unpaid…